Furnace Warning Signs to Catch Before Winter Sets In

Service First technician working on an indoor heating unit

Most furnaces give you some kind of hint before they quit, and the trick is knowing which hints mean “get out of the house” and which mean “put a visit on the calendar this week.” A new rattle, a smell you can’t place, or a bedroom that never quite warms up are easy to shrug off in November. Would you rather find out on the first night the temperature drops into the teens? This guide sorts the most common furnace warning signs by how fast you should act, so you can make a calm call instead of a panicked one.

Simple Triage: Leave Now, Shut It Off, or Book a Visit

Not every odd noise is an emergency, and not every quiet furnace is a healthy one. Here is a simple way to sort what you notice.

Leave the house and call from outside

Two signs skip the line every time. If you smell gas, even faintly and even if you aren’t sure, leave the home right away with everyone in it. Trane’s advice is to leave immediately and call 911, then contact an HVAC professional from a safe location. On the way out, don’t flip light switches, use phones or appliances, or do anything that could make a spark, and don’t try to find the leak yourself. Once you’re outside, you can also call your gas utility’s emergency line. Don’t go back in until emergency responders or the utility say it’s safe. If a carbon monoxide alarm sounds, the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission says to never ignore the alarm, get outside immediately and call 911. Carbon monoxide is an odorless, colorless and toxic gas, according to the EPA, so you can’t see or smell it. A working alarm is your best warning. The EPA also notes symptoms such as headache, dizziness and flu-like symptoms that clear up after leaving home; if people in the house feel that way, get outside and call 911. Do not go back in to look for the cause.

Turn the furnace off and call a technician

Some signs are not an evacuation, but they are a reason to stop running the furnace until someone checks it. Trane lists yellow or flickering flames instead of a steady blue flame, soot buildup around the furnace or flue pipe, a strong metallic odor, and a carbon monoxide detector that keeps tripping among the warning signs of a cracked heat exchanger. If a carbon monoxide alarm sounds, treat it as an emergency first: get outside and call 911, as described above, and have the furnace checked before it runs again. A crack can only be confirmed by a technician, and our guide to the signs of a cracked furnace heat exchanger walks through what you can and can’t see from the outside.

Book a visit before the cold settles in

The third group won’t send you outside, but it’s worth booking before it turns into a no-heat call. New noises, short cycling, rooms that stay cold, a furnace that needs resetting, and heating bills that climb for no clear reason all belong here. Calling while the weather is still mild means you get a time that suits you, not whatever is left during a cold snap.

Telltale Sounds From the Basement

A furnace makes a few normal sounds, like the click of the igniter and the hum of the blower. What you want to notice is anything new. Trane says loud hissing or banging noises could indicate a larger problem, and that strange noises may also point to an electrical issue. Banging or rattling can also show up on Trane’s list of cracked heat exchanger signs, which is one more reason not to guess at the cause.

Squeals, screeches and grinding are worth mentioning to your technician, too. Try to note when the sound happens. Does it start right when the furnace kicks on, while the blower runs, or right after it shuts off? That one detail can save your technician time and save you a second visit.

Unusual Smells Worth Taking Seriously

Any smell of gas is a reason to leave first and ask questions later. You don’t have to judge how strong it is: if it smells like gas to you, get everyone out and call 911 from outside.

Other smells fall in the “turn it off and call” group. A strong metallic odor is one of Trane’s warning signs. A smell that seems to come from the furnace while it runs is also worth a call.

If your home heats with oil, a strong oil odor or soot near the burner is a reason to have the system looked at. Service First services and repairs oil furnaces and oil boilers. If your oil system has shut itself down, read when to reset an oil furnace or boiler, and when to stop before you press the button a second time.

Visible Clues Around the Furnace

You don’t need to open any panels to spot trouble, and you shouldn’t. Removing furnace panels is a job for a technician. Stick to what you can see from the outside.

  • Flame color. On older furnaces with a visible flame, Trane says yellow or uneven flames instead of blue ones may mean dirty burners. Newer models use electric ignition and may not show a flame at all.
  • Soot or scorch marks around the furnace, the flue pipe or the registers.
  • Water on the floor near the furnace. High-efficiency furnaces make water as part of normal operation, so a puddle usually points to a drain problem. Our post on why water leaks from a furnace covers the usual causes.
  • Heavy rust or corrosion on the cabinet or flue. Trane lists corrosion or rust on the heat exchanger among its cracked heat exchanger signs, and only a technician can check that part.
  • A blinking status light. Many furnaces flash a code when something trips. Our furnace error code guide explains how to read it and when to stop resetting.

Costly Patterns in Comfort and Bills

Some warning signs show up on your thermostat and your utility bill, not in the basement. ENERGY STAR lists equipment that needs frequent repairs while energy bills go up, rooms that are too hot or too cold, and a noisy system among the signs it may be time to look at your heating equipment.

Watch for a furnace that turns on and off in short bursts. That pattern, called short cycling, is worth having checked, and Trane lists it among the signs of a cracked heat exchanger. Our post on why a furnace turns on and off repeatedly explains what drives it. A furnace that runs and runs without reaching the set temperature belongs in the same group.

If your furnace keeps needing repairs, it may be time to weigh the bigger question. Our guide to furnace repair vs replacement goes through the numbers.

Smart Steps You Can Take Today

A few homeowner checks can rule out the simple stuff and keep a small problem from snowballing.

  1. Check the air filter. ENERGY STAR says to inspect, clean or change air filters once a month in your furnace. A clogged filter chokes airflow and makes the furnace work harder.
  2. Check the thermostat and the breaker. If the furnace won’t start at all, our checklist for a furnace that’s not heating covers settings, the breaker and the power switch.
  3. Clear the vents. Make sure furniture, rugs and curtains aren’t blocking registers or return air vents. In snowy weather, the CPSC also advises clearing snow away from the outside vents for fuel-burning appliances such as furnaces.
  4. Test your carbon monoxide alarms. The CPSC recommends battery-operated alarms, or alarms with battery backup, on each level of the home and outside separate sleeping areas.
  5. Plan a yearly check-up. The EPA advises having a trained professional inspect, clean and tune up your central heating system, including furnaces, flues and chimneys, every year. ENERGY STAR suggests checking the heating system in the fall, before contractors get busy.

Round-the-Clock Help in Bucks County and Nearby New Jersey

Service First has looked after homes in Bucks County since 2009, from our shop on South Lincoln Avenue in Newtown out to Doylestown, Yardley, Langhorne and Warminster, plus nearby Montgomery County and the New Jersey towns across the river such as Lambertville, Pennington and Princeton. We are licensed in Pennsylvania and New Jersey, we are an independent Trane Comfort Specialist dealer, and we service gas, oil and heat pump systems.

If you spotted a warning sign on this list, you have three easy ways to reach us:

  • Call (215) 876-0486. Our office is open about 7:30 AM to 3:30 PM, Monday to Friday, and 24/7 emergency service is available.
  • Schedule a furnace repair visit online at a time that fits your week.
  • Weighing a new system instead? The Instant HVAC Pricing Tool gives you a realistic local price range in a few quick steps, with no obligation. It is an estimate, and exact pricing comes after an in-home visit.

Learn more about our furnace repair service, and if your home heats with a boiler, see our boiler service page.

Stay warm and toasty this winter, and keep our number on your speed dial. Service First Heating & Air Conditioning, where service comes first.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is it normal for a furnace to smell when it first turns on for the season?

Don’t try to decide that on your own. If what you smell is gas, or might be gas, leave the house with everyone in it, call 911 from outside and then call a heating professional. Don’t use switches or phones inside on the way out. If the smell is something else and keeps coming back every time the furnace runs, turn the furnace off and have it checked.

What should I do if my carbon monoxide alarm goes off?

Get everyone outside right away and call 911, as the U.S. Consumer Product Safety Commission advises. Do not go back in until emergency responders say it is safe, and have the furnace checked by a technician before it runs again.

Can I keep running my furnace if it is making a new banging noise?

A new bang or rattle is a reason to have the furnace checked soon, and Trane lists banging or rattling among the signs of a cracked heat exchanger. If the noise comes with a smell, soot or a yellow flame, turn the furnace off and call a technician. If a carbon monoxide alarm sounds, get everyone outside and call 911 first.

How often should I change my furnace filter?

ENERGY STAR says to inspect, clean or change your furnace filter once a month. Some filters last longer, but checking it every month is the safe habit during heating season.

Does Service First repair oil furnaces?

Yes. Service First services and repairs oil furnaces and oil boilers, along with gas furnaces, boilers and heat pumps.

Share:
Facebook
Twitter
WhatsApp
Telegram
Email
Compliance Settings
Increase Font Size
Grayscale
Simplified Font
Underline Links
Highlight Links
Reset
Close